Thursday, June 10, 2010

Patrick Kane's Stanley Cup Clinching Goal Left Announcers Everywhere Quite Confused

I mentioned in my recap last night how every call of the goal was of initial confusion and the city of Chicago has no great call to relive. I said that after only viewing Doc Emrick and Jim Hughson call it. Well now I have heard Dave Strader on the NHL's international feed, John Wiederman on WGN Radio in Chicago, and Pierre Hourde on the French-speaking RDS, and guess what, they were all confused as well. Literally everyone initially missed it, and if they thought they saw it go in right away (which to their credit, Hourde and Wiederman actually did), they quickly backtracked because there was no whistle, no red light, and goal signal from the refs. Notably in the case of Emrick and WGN's radio PbP announcer (John Wiederman), they saw things they did not acutally see. So without further ado, here are the 5 most confused Stanley Cup clinching goal calls in the history of hockey!

First, Doc Emrick on NBC.



Secondly, Jim Hughson on CBC.



Thirdly, Pierre Hourde gives his call on the French-Canadian channel, RDS.



Next up, Dave Strader on the NHL's International feed.



Now, John Wiederman on WGN Radio imagines an odd sequence of events leading to the puck getting into the net.



So now the question of whose is the best? I can't understand everything Hourde is saying (though enough to know that he did think it was in before back-tracking for a brief seconds), Jim Hughson started imagining things, back-tracked, then went into a lame and unenthusiastic pre-scripted call, and while Wiederman had the most excitement (and why not, he is a local radio announcer), he was the most confused of the 5 at first and had the most bizarre imagination. So it's down to Doc and Strader. Mike Emrick imagined things, Strader was merely confused. Strader realized it was a goal before Kane reached the blue line, Emrick realized it after Kane passed the blue line, and both were fairly excited. On that note, I think the winner of best call goes to Dave Strader with Doc in 2nd. Make no mistake about it, though, what we have here are the 5 worst Cup clinching goal calls in NHL history.

2 comments:

  1. Train wreck announcing but I say Strader 1st and Hughson 2nd.

    What makes this suck even more is it was on the road. Unless the traveling fans are great (lots of Pens fans in Detroit) I hate it when a title is clinched on the road.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @ SSR: Philly fans booed Bettman and were a tad upset Toews won Conn Smythe, but when the cup came out, they all stayed and applauded, so it was not a total loss for Chicago.

    ReplyDelete

Read the Commenting Guidelines before commenting.